Being in pastry, I have no problem using a recipe. I even slightly dislike when sneering cooks say to each other “oh my god dude, I can’t believe you need a recipe for that”. Standard recipes are not only the only way to control food cost, but they are also the only way to maintain standard flavours from one day to the next and one cook to the next. Yes you should know how to make a tomato soup without a recipe, but in a professional kitchen, having a standard recipe is essential. 12 different cooks will make 12 completely different tomato soups.
That said, not all recipes are created equal, or are all even any good. There is pretty much nothing I hate more than someone asking for me to make something stupid that I don’t have a good recipe for, then handing me a printout from all recipes, or about.com. Even printouts from respectable sources are often not suitable for production kitchens, with ingredients in cups, or bags, or handfuls. There is no substitute for trustworthy recipes that you know will work with your oven, available ingredients and equipment.
What is “acceptable” to a home baker in terms of a final product will not necessarily be good enough to be used in your establishment where anything less than “great” is simply not good enough. Book recipes are a lot more trustworthy in general because of the accountability involved. A recipe that gets a complaint from bonappetit.com, can be taken down within a few hours, but a bad recipe in their published book will damage their brand with everyone who tries it out over the lifetime of the book. But again, there are good books (The New Best Recipe, Bon Appetite Desserts, Indulge, Canadian Living Baking book, and Michel Roux Pastry are but a few) and bad books, but I’ll take a book recipe over a printout any day.


I’ve written about podcasts before, when I shared 


